Bacopa monnieri vs Lion's mane mushroom
Evidence grades side by side for every outcome Bacopa monnieri or Lion's mane mushroom has graded.
Grades side by side
| Outcome | Bacopa monnieri | Lion's mane mushroom |
|---|---|---|
| Reaction time | Not graded | C Limited for Lion's mane mushroom, Reaction time: read the rationaleNo effect found |
| Perceived stress | C Limited for Bacopa monnieri, Perceived stress: read the rationaleBenefit found | C Limited for Lion's mane mushroom, Perceived stress: read the rationaleNo effect found |
| Processing speed | C Limited for Bacopa monnieri, Processing speed: read the rationaleNo effect found | Not graded |
| Acute cognitive performance | C Limited for Bacopa monnieri, Acute cognitive performance: read the rationaleNo effect found | Not graded |
| Global cognition | Not graded | C Limited for Lion's mane mushroom, Global cognition: read the rationaleBenefit found |
| Delayed recall | B Moderate for Bacopa monnieri, Delayed recall: read the rationaleBenefit found | Not graded |
| Safety | Safety section | Safety section |
Doses used in studies
Bacopa monnieri
- 300-450 mg extract a day12-week memory and cognition trials
- 300 and 600 mg a day12-week trial in older adults
- low dose 300 to under 600 mg a day; high dose 600 mg a day or moreNetwork meta-analysis dose groups
- 300 mg; 320 mg and 640 mgSingle-dose trials
Lion's mane mushroom
- four 250 mg tablets three times a day (3.0 g/day) for 16 weeksOlder adults with mild cognitive impairment
- 3.2 g/day fruiting body powder for 12 weeksHealthy older adults
- three 350 mg erinacine A-enriched mycelium capsules a day for 49 weeksMild Alzheimer's disease (clinical population)
- 1 g to 3 g of extract as a single dose; 1.8 g/day to 10 g/day for 4 weeksYounger adults (healthy, or young women reporting stress or anxiety)
Grades describe the evidence for each outcome, not a recommendation, and a higher grade for one compound does not mean it works better than the other. Open a grade for its rationale and dated history. Doses are the ranges researchers used, not dosing advice. How we gradeDisclaimer
More to compare
Written comparisons
- Beta-alanine vs creatine: what the evidence shows
- Magnesium vs melatonin: what the evidence shows
- Alpha-GPC vs citicoline: what the evidence shows
- Ashwagandha vs Rhodiola rosea: what the evidence shows
- Caffeine vs creatine: what the evidence shows
- Bacopa monnieri vs Ginkgo biloba: what the evidence shows
- Caffeine vs L-theanine: what the evidence shows